Hire purchase and leasing are both financing options available to businesses and individuals in the United Kingdom. There are a number of key differences between the two options that should be considered before making a decision.
1. What is hire purchase, and what is leasing?
A hire purchase is a financing agreement where the buyer makes regular payments to the lender over an agreed period. The agreement will also specify an option-to-purchase price, which is the amount the buyer will need to pay to take ownership of the asset at the end of the hire period.
Leasing is a financing agreement where the lender agrees to provide the use of an asset for an agreed period in exchange for regular payments from the lessee. At the end of the leasing period, the lessee will have the option to purchase the asset for a pre-agreed price.
2. The benefits of hire purchase over leasing
Several benefits hire purchase offers over leasing are:
- Hire purchase agreements usually have shorter terms than leasing agreements, which means that the buyer will take ownership of the asset sooner.
- Hire purchase payments are usually lower than leasing payments, as the buyer only pays for a portion of the asset’s value each month.
- Hire purchase agreements often come with balloon payments, a lump sum payment made at the end of the hire period. This can make it easier to budget for the purchase of the asset.
- Hire purchase agreements to give the buyer the option to purchase the asset at the end of the hire period, meaning they will own the asset outright.
On the other hand, leasing agreements give the lessee the option to purchase the asset at the end of the leasing period. However, this purchase price is often higher than the asset’s market value, which means that the lessee will not own the asset outright.
3. How to go about hiring a purchase agreement
When purchasing an asset, shopping around for the best deal is important. There are several hire purchase companies in the UK, so it is important to compare interest rates and terms before making a decision.
It is also important to carefully read the hire purchase agreement before signing it. This document will outline the terms of the agreement, including the interest rate, monthly payment amount, and option-to-purchase price.
4. The importance of reading the fine print before signing any contract
It is important to read any contract carefully before signing it. This includes a hire purchase and leasing contracts. You will know your rights and obligations under the agreement by reading the contract.
5. Things you should keep in mind when considering a hire purchase or lease agreement
There are many things that you should keep in mind when considering a hire purchase or lease agreement:
- First, consider the agreement’s length and whether you can make the monthly payments.
- Secondly, you should consider the option-to-purchase price and whether you can afford this at the end of the hire period.
- Finally, it would be best to read the contract thoroughly before signing it to understand your rights and obligations.
Tax Implications: Hire Purchase vs. Leasing
Understanding the tax implications of hire purchase and leasing is crucial for businesses that want to optimise their financial strategies. Both options offer distinct tax benefits and considerations, which can influence the overall cost and financial attractiveness of each option.
Tax Deductions
Hire Purchase
- Depreciation and Interest Deduction: With a hire purchase agreement, because the buyer typically takes ownership of the asset, it is considered part of the company’s capital. As such, the business can claim capital allowances, including depreciation, as a tax deduction. This allows the company to spread the cost of the asset over its useful life, reducing taxable profits each year.
- Interest Deductibility: The interest component of the hire purchase payments can also be deducted as a business expense. This further reduces the taxable income of the business, making hire purchase an attractive option for companies looking to lower their tax burden over time.
Leasing
- Operating Expense Deduction: Leasing often allows businesses to deduct the full amount of lease payments as an operating expense on their income statement. This reduces the company’s taxable income in the year the lease payments are made. Unlike hire purchase, where deductions are spread out through depreciation, leasing offers immediate tax relief.
- Capital Lease Considerations: If the lease is classified as a capital lease (or finance lease), the asset may be recorded on the balance sheet, and the business can claim depreciation similar to a hire purchase. However, lease payments in this scenario are treated differently, with only the interest portion being deductible. The distinction between operating and capital leases is important, as it impacts the tax treatment and financial reporting of the leased asset.
VAT Treatment
Hire Purchase
- Upfront VAT Payment: In a hire purchase agreement, VAT is typically due on the entire value of the asset at the beginning of the agreement. This means that the buyer must pay the VAT upfront. However, businesses that are VAT-registered can usually reclaim this VAT, either immediately or over time, depending on the specific regulations and the company’s VAT accounting method.
- VAT on Interest Payments: The VAT treatment in hire purchase agreements can vary depending on the terms. Generally, VAT is not charged on the interest portion of the payments, which can make hire purchase slightly more VAT-efficient compared to leasing.
Leasing
- VAT Spread Across Lease Payments: In leasing agreements, VAT is usually applied to each individual lease payment rather than upfront. This means that the VAT cost is spread over the duration of the lease, which can improve cash flow for businesses by avoiding a large upfront VAT payment. The VAT on lease payments is typically reclaimable by VAT-registered businesses, making leasing an attractive option for managing VAT payments in a more staggered manner.
- Operating vs. Finance Lease VAT Treatment: The VAT treatment can differ slightly between operating and finance leases. In operating leases, VAT is generally charged on the full amount of each lease payment. In finance leases, the VAT may be treated differently, depending on whether the lease is considered a supply of goods or a supply of services under local VAT rules. Understanding these nuances is essential for accurately forecasting VAT liabilities and cash flow impacts.
Impact on Cash Flow and Balance Sheet
When choosing between hire purchase and leasing, it’s essential to consider how each option will impact your company’s cash flow and balance sheet. These financial implications can significantly influence your business’s liquidity, financial ratios, and overall financial health.
Cash Flow Considerations
Hire Purchase
- Upfront Costs: One of the main features of a hire purchase agreement is that it often requires a larger initial payment, which may include a deposit or the first instalment. Additionally, some hire purchase agreements include a balloon payment at the end of the term, which is a lump sum payment to finalise ownership of the asset. These payments can significantly impact cash flow, especially for businesses with tight liquidity.
- Payment Structure: While hire purchase allows the spreading of payments over time, the overall cash outflow is generally higher compared to leasing because the goal is to eventually own the asset. This means that monthly payments may be slightly higher, and the business needs to plan for the potential impact of these payments on its cash reserves.
- Budgeting and Planning: The fixed nature of hire purchase payments can make budgeting easier, but businesses must account for the larger outflows at the beginning and end of the agreement. This requires careful financial planning to ensure that the business has the necessary cash flow to meet these obligations without affecting other operational needs.
Leasing
- Smaller, Consistent Payments: Leasing typically involves smaller, consistent payments spread over the term of the lease. This can be advantageous for cash flow management, as it allows businesses to preserve cash for other operational needs or investments. The predictability of lease payments makes it easier to budget for expenses without the concern of large, one-time payments.
- Flexibility in Payment Terms: Leasing agreements can often be tailored to the cash flow needs of the business, with options such as seasonal payment structures or step-up leases where payments start lower and increase over time. This flexibility can be beneficial for businesses that experience fluctuating cash flow throughout the year.
- No Balloon Payments: Unlike hire purchase, leasing does not usually require a large payment at the end of the term. This means that businesses can avoid the potential cash flow strain of a balloon payment, making leasing a more cash flow-friendly option, particularly for businesses that prioritise liquidity.
Balance Sheet Implications
Hire Purchase
- Asset Ownership: Under a hire purchase agreement, the asset is typically recorded on the company’s balance sheet as a fixed asset, even though full ownership transfers only at the end of the agreement. This means that the business shows the asset as part of its total assets, along with a corresponding liability for the outstanding payments.
- Depreciation and Liabilities: The asset is subject to depreciation, which reduces its value on the balance sheet over time. Simultaneously, the liability associated with the hire purchase agreement decreases as payments are made. This can impact financial ratios, such as return on assets (ROA) and debt-to-equity ratios, which may be important for stakeholders or when seeking financing.
- Impact on Financial Ratios: Because the asset and liability both appear on the balance sheet, hire purchase can affect key financial metrics. For example, increasing liabilities might impact the company’s gearing ratio (debt to equity), potentially affecting its creditworthiness or attractiveness to investors.
Leasing
- Operating Lease vs. Finance Lease: The impact on the balance sheet varies depending on whether the lease is classified as an operating lease or a finance lease. Operating leases still offer some off-balance-sheet benefits under certain conditions, though these are increasingly limited. In contrast, finance leases are treated similarly to hire purchase, with the asset and liability both appearing on the balance sheet.
- Financial Flexibility: Leasing can offer greater financial flexibility by not tying up capital in owned assets. However, the new accounting standards require careful management of lease liabilities to ensure that they do not negatively impact financial ratios. Businesses need to assess how the inclusion of these liabilities will affect their overall financial position and reporting.
Hire purchase and leasing are both financing options with advantages and disadvantages. It is important to consider these before making a decision. Ultimately, the best option for you will depend on your circumstances.
Get in touch with one of our professionals at Funding Bay today for your hire purchase and leasing needs.
Check out our Asset Finance Calculator.
